What Is the Best Way to Cover a Window Well?

If you’re looking for the best way to cover a window well, you’ve likely realized there are quite a few options—each with its own pros and cons. Whether you're trying to keep out water, debris, animals, or protect loved ones from falling in, your choice of window well cover matters. In this post, we’ll break down the most common types and explain why Feldhawk’s metal window well covers are the top-tier solution.

1. Thin Plastic Window Well Covers: The Budget Option

The cheapest and most widely available option is the thin, clear plastic cover found at many hardware stores. These covers sit over your window well and act as a simple barrier to rain, leaves, and other debris.

Pros:

• Very affordable

• Easy to find

• Keeps out water and most debris

Cons:

• Not weight-rated—if someone steps on one, it can crack or collapse

• Prone to sun damage, cracking, and discoloration over time

• Typically needs to be replaced every few years

Plastic window well covers are a temporary fix at best and not suitable for households where safety and longevity are priorities.

2. Thick Polycarbonate Covers: Mid-Range Performance

A step up from the thin plastic options, thick polycarbonate window well covers offer a little more durability and a clearer view into the well. These covers are often marketed for their light-transmitting properties.

Pros:

• Allows the most natural light into the well

• Better debris protection than thin plastic

• Slightly improved weight rating

Cons:

• Still not rated for substantial weight—don’t expect it to safely support a person

• Aesthetically plain and often bulky

• Can discolor or become cloudy over time

While polycarbonate covers may last longer than the cheapest plastic ones, they’re still lacking in both visual appeal and real safety performance.

3. Metal Window Well Covers: Strongest & Safest Option

For maximum protection, durability, and style, metal window well covers are the best choice—especially those from Feldhawk.

Feldhawk’s metal window well covers are designed to check every box:

• Debris protection

• Weather resistance

• Exceptional strength

• Architectural appeal

Our 11-gauge powder-coated steel covers support up to 400 lbs of weight, meaning they can safely hold the weight of children, pets, and even most adults—eliminating the safety concerns found in plastic and polycarbonate options.

Plus, Feldhawk offers decorative styles like the Chevron, Victorian, and Diamond cut-out patterns—giving your home an elegant, finished look. All covers are finished in a sleek black powder coat that resists rust and wear, even in harsh weather.

Pros:

• Holds up to 400 lbs for superior safety

• Keeps out leaves, trash, animals, and rain

• Allows light to enter the well

• Stylish, decorative patterns to enhance curb appeal

• Long-lasting and rust-resistant

Cons:

• Higher initial investment—but far fewer replacements over time

  
  

So, What’s the Best Way to Cover a Window Well?

While plastic and polycarbonate covers may work in the short term, Feldhawk metal window well covers offer the best long-term protection, durability, and design. With unmatched strength, decorative options, and rust resistance, Feldhawk covers are built to last—and built to look good doing it.

Shop all Feldhawk Window Well Covers here.